
How to manage candidate experience in executive recruitment
Create a positive candidate experience in executive recruitment with fair and transparent processes to build trust and attract senior leaders.
How to create a positive candidate experience
Executive recruitment can fail candidates when everyone assumes someone else is holding the relationship. For example, this can happen with an internal applicant or perhaps someone close to the employer, where there is an assumption about how these particular applicants are being stewarded.
In values-led search, candidate care is co-owned:
- The client owns setting a clear process, keeping to timelines where possible, and making fair, well-explained decisions.
- The search partner owns communication, guidance, confidentiality and a process that feels fair and respectful.
- Both own the tone: how you show up, listen and challenge supportively, and how you close the loop.
When we share responsibility in this way, it shows in how we protect confidentiality, treat people with respect and handle their information with care.
Before you go to market, align on what you want candidates to feel.
A simple charter can cover:
- What updates candidates can expect, and how often
- How you will handle delays, changes and uncertainty
- How you will offer and manage reasonable adjustments
- What “good feedback” looks like at each stage
- What you will do to protect confidentiality and minimise exposure
This outline protects candidate dignity and strengthens decision quality. When people experience a process that feels fair and transparent, it builds trust and makes them more likely to say yes.
Read more: Write an inclusive job description to attract diverse candidates
Category:Client advice

Written by
James Hunt
Director | Membership & Development
James Hunt is a senior executive search specialist with over two decades of experience connecting exceptional leaders with purpose-driven organisations. As Head of Not for Profit Appointments at Peridot Partners, he has led 300 specialist, senior and board-level searches across the UK's charity, membership and higher-education sectors.
His portfolio spans appointments for organisations as wide-ranging as the Chartered Insurance Institute, Stonewall, University of London, IOSH and Migrant Help. James is trusted for his insight, rigour and empathy when working with boards navigating complexity or transition.
Inclusive recruitment is central to his approach. As a proud member of the LGBTQ+ community, neurodivergent and an immigrant who has made the UK home, James draws on lived experience to embed fairness and belonging into every search. He is a Trustee and sits on two Committees of a large charity, and is a member of Peridot's EDI, L&D and People Committees. He actively challenges assumptions, opens space for underrepresented voices and builds transparent, psychologically safe recruitment journeys.
James believes that great leadership is grounded in vulnerability, creativity and empathy. These values shape his work with candidates and clients alike, helping to build long-term relationships and leadership teams that reflect the societies they serve.
Related articles

How to hire for culture add, not just culture fit
Read further
Why executive search matters in higher education fundraising recruitment
Read further
Acting CEO vs interim CEO: what’s in a job title?
Read further
Challenges in charity leadership recruitment in divisive times
Read further
The impact of FE leadership recruitment on student success and college performance
Read further
7 common hiring mistakes and how to avoid them
Read further
Attract top talent in a competitive market
Read further
Why successful charity recruitment relies on stakeholder sessions
Read further
How can salary surveys help you attract and retain the best talent?
Read further
Strengthening social justice through inclusive recruitment.
Read further
Why social impact matters in recruitment
Read further