Candidates’ guide to preparing for a charity panel interview

Candidates’ guide to preparing for a charity panel interview

By Simon Callaghan|22 July 2025

Get ready for your charity panel interview with practical tips on questions, preparation, and how to connect with every panellist in the room.

Interview questions are often drawn directly from the job description, and panel members will be listening for certain words, themes or priorities that match their expectations.

From there, expect questions that test:

  • How you work with others, especially across teams or functions.
  • How you solve problems under pressure or with limited resources.
  • How you reflect the charity’s values in your day-to-day decisions.
  • How you’ve delivered impact, even in challenging or uncertain contexts.

Using the STAR method (Situation, Task, Action, Result) can help you structure your answers clearly. It also makes it easier for the panel to follow your thinking and see your role in what happened.

You don’t need to cover every part of the job description in each answer. Instead, focus on one outcome per question and aim to reflect different priorities across the interview as a whole.

3. Practise and manage delivery

How you deliver your answers in a charity interview matters as much as the content itself. Practise speaking clearly, keeping your answers focused and responding in a way that feels confident and considered.

Start by running through mock interviews with a friend or colleague. Practising in a panel-style setting can help you get more comfortable making eye contact, managing nerves and thinking on your feet. It also gives you a chance to get feedback on your tone and body language, which are usually hard to judge on your own.

Try to keep each answer to around two minutes to set the scene, explain what you did and reflect on the result. If you tend to go off track or overexplain, set a timer to help you build awareness of pacing.

Recording yourself can also be useful. You might notice habits you weren’t aware of, such as rushing your words, repeating certain phrases or dropping energy halfway through a response.

If you’re feeling nervous, pause for a moment before the interview starts. Take a deep breath, drop your shoulders and settle into your seat to help you stay present and communicate more clearly.

4. Prepare your materials

Bring everything you need to stay organised on the day and make a strong first impression.

Most panellists will have digital access to your CV, but printed copies can be helpful. It gives people something to refer to as you speak and can make your experience easier to follow, especially if you’re talking through complex roles or career changes.

Taking notes can show you’re engaged, listening carefully and treating the interview as a two-way conversation. Just avoid relying on your notepad so much that it breaks your connection with the panel.

Prepare one or two questions to ask at the end to show you’re thinking about your long-term impact. Focus on what you’re curious about, whether that’s the charity’s direction, the team’s way of working, or how success will be measured in the role.

If the role involves writing, campaigns or strategy, you might want to bring examples of your work to refer to. And if you’ve agreed any interview adjustments, bring whatever you need to feel comfortable and confident.

Category:Candidate advice

Share:
Simon Callaghan

Written by

Simon Callaghan

Partner

Simon Callaghan leads the Fundraising and Marketing and Communications Recruitment teams at Peridot. He has successfully recruited key roles for national and international charities, including the International Rescue Committee, WWF, The Prince's Trust, Prostate Cancer UK, and The Royal Marsden Cancer Charity. His work with the International Rescue Committee was instrumental in their team winning the Institute of Fundraising's Fundraising Team of the Year award.

Beyond his professional achievements, Simon is deeply committed to the fundraising sector. He serves on the committee of the Institute of Fundraising's Major Donor Special Interest Group, promoting shared learning and best practice. Simon advocates for increasing the presence of professional fundraisers on trustee boards, collaborating with chairs and CEOs to bring in first-time trustees with income generation expertise.

When not working in fundraising, Simon enjoys a wide range of music, supports Norwich City Football Club, is an enthusiastic golfer, and finds entertainment in his two young sons' antics.